How to host a murder mystery dinner? A complete guide for Australians

Take a Chef Team

October 23, 2025

How to host a murder mystery dinner?

Are you looking for a fun, interactive, and unforgettable way to entertain your friends and family in Australia? A murder mystery dinner might be just the thing!

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, hosting a casual get-together, or organising a special event, a murder mystery dinner offers the perfect mix of suspense, drama, and entertainment.

In this guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to host a thrilling murder mystery dinner, from selecting a theme to choosing the perfect menu.

How to choose right theme for a murder mystery dinner?

The theme sets the tone for the entire evening, so it’s essential to choose one that will resonate with your guests and create a memorable experience.

When hosting an Australian murder mystery dinner, consider themes that reflect local culture, interests, and traditions, alongside timeless classics. Here are some fun and exciting ideas for your dinner theme:

  • Classic Whodunit: a tried-and-tested theme that never goes out of style. Inspired by iconic detectives such as Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot, a classic whodunit involves guests playing the role of investigators and suspects in a crime. Everyone has a role to play, and they must follow the clues to uncover the murderer.
  • Australian Outback Mystery: imagine a murder set in the vast and mysterious Australian outback, filled with rugged landscapes and local legends. Guests can embody characters like bushrangers, cattle station owners, and adventurous explorers. This theme combines elements of adventure, mystery, and a dash of Aussie charm.
  • Sydney Harbour Heist: set in the dazzling heart of Sydney, this theme revolves around a glamorous heist during a luxurious dinner cruise or fancy gala. It’s perfect for a sophisticated crowd and offers plenty of opportunities for guests to don their best tuxedos and evening gowns.
  • 1920s Gatsby Glamour: the roaring 20s never fail to captivate. The opulence of the time, filled with jazz, flappers, and secretive speakeasies, makes it the ideal setting for a murder mystery dinner. Think of Gatsby-inspired parties where guests can enjoy all the glitz and glamour of the jazz age.
  • A Haunted House Mystery: for those who enjoy a spooky vibe, a haunted house or ghostly mansion can provide the perfect backdrop for a chilling mystery. Perfect for a Halloween dinner or just a thrill-seeking group of friends, this theme brings drama and suspense to your dinner party.

The theme you choose should not only fit the interests of your guests but also help guide your costume choices, the setting, and the overall vibe of the evening. The more immersive the theme, the better the experience!

Selecting a murder mystery game kit or hiring a professional host

Once you’ve nailed down the theme, it’s time to think about how to organise the mystery itself. You have two main options when it comes to running the event:

Pre-packaged murder mystery kits

If you’re after a simple solution that takes the guesswork out of hosting, consider purchasing a pre-packaged murder mystery kit. These kits are widely available online and include everything you need: character roles, scripts, clues, and instructions.

Many kits are based on popular themes, such as a Victorian dinner party or an old Hollywood murder, and they’re perfect for a DIY event.

Hiring a professional host

If you want to take your dinner party to the next level and ensure a smooth and exciting experience, you may want to hire a professional murder mystery organiser. A professional can guide the entire event, keep the suspense high, and make sure everyone stays engaged.

They will run the game, provide the clues, and even give you the option to customise the storyline to match your theme. This is ideal for those who want to avoid the stress of organising the event themselves.

Create the perfect murder mystery menu with a private chef

Food plays an integral part in creating a memorable murder mystery dinner. A themed menu can help immerse your guests in the story and elevate the entire experience.

Here’s how you can match your dinner menu with your chosen theme:

  • For the Sydney Harbour Heist theme, you could serve dishes like grilled lobster, seafood platters, or even gourmet Australian bush tucker (native ingredients like wattleseed and kangaroo). Finish off with a decadent dessert like pavlova, the iconic Aussie treat.
  • For a 1920s Gatsby-themed dinner, offer a menu of opulent dishes, such as caviar, shrimp cocktails, filet mignon, and champagne cocktails. You could even add an Australian twist with a gourmet lamington or Anzac biscuits for dessert.
  • For the Australian Outback theme, you can feature a hearty menu with BBQ steaks, lamb, kangaroo fillets, and sides of roasted veggies. A rustic dessert, such as a classic Australian damper or pavlova, would fit perfectly into this menu.

For a seamless dining experience, consider hiring a private chef for the night! A private chef will create a menu tailored to your theme. Hiring a chef can also take the pressure off you, letting you enjoy the evening with your guests while indulging in a high-quality meal.

Events & Ideas

Unforgettable moments with gourmet touches

From intimate dinners to special celebrations, our private chefs create memorable experiences that turn any event into something extraordinary.

Setting the scene: decorations and ambience

Creating the right atmosphere is key to immersing your guests in the mystery. Here are some tips on setting the scene:

  • Lighting: low lighting can set the perfect tone. If you’re hosting a Halloween mystery, consider eerie lighting or flickering candles. For a Sydney Harbour or 1920s theme, consider elegant soft lighting or chandelier lights to keep it classy.
  • Music: music can enhance the ambiance. For a 1920s Gatsby night, jazz or big band music will take your guests back in time. If you’ve chosen an Australian outback theme, consider playing classic Aussie country tunes in the background.
  • Decorations: transform your space to match your theme. For a Sydney Harbour Heist, you might decorate with nautical elements like ropes, anchors, and navy colours. For a classic whodunit, use props like old detective tools, crime scene tape, and mystery novels.

Adding small, immersive details such as themed place cards, period-appropriate décor, or even a hidden clue can elevate the experience.

Assigning characters and crafting the plot for your murder mystery dinner

One of the most important elements of any murder mystery dinner is character assignment. To ensure your guests are fully engaged in the mystery, assign characters ahead of time and provide each guest with a detailed profile. Each character should have a backstory, secrets, and objectives for the evening, and they should be encouraged to interact with other guests, exchanging clues and working together to solve the crime.

It’s also important to pace the story. Begin by explaining the scenario and setting the stage for the crime. Throughout the night, reveal key clues at appropriate moments, keeping the suspense high. Timing is crucial to building tension and excitement.

Hosting the murder mystery dinner

As the host, your role is to keep the event flowing smoothly and ensure that everyone is having fun. Here are some tips for managing the evening:

  • Set expectations: at the beginning of the night, explain the rules and structure of the evening. Outline the timeline, the objectives, and encourage your guests to get involved and work together.
  • Encourage interaction: make sure your guests are interacting with each other, asking questions, and sharing clues. The more engaged they are, the more enjoyable the night will be for everyone.
  • Unveil the clue at the right time: keep your guests on the edge of their seats by revealing clues at crucial moments. The climax should come towards the end of the evening, when everyone is ready to make their final guesses.

At the end of the night, offer a small prize to the person who solves the mystery, or for the most creative theory. This gives your guests a memorable takeaway from the night.

The grand finale for your unforgettable murder mystery dinner!

Hosting a murder mystery dinner is a unique and entertaining way to spend time with friends, family, or colleagues in Australia. With the right theme, menu, and atmosphere, you can create an immersive and thrilling experience that will have everyone talking long after the mystery is solved.

By selecting the perfect theme, offering a delicious meal prepared by a private chef, and keeping your guests engaged throughout the night, you’re sure to host a successful and memorable murder mystery dinner. So, gather your guests, set the stage, and let the intrigue begin!


Recent Articles